by Juliana Dal Piva and Cleber Lourenço
Meta, the parent company of Instagram, informed the Electoral Court in September that it had preserved data related to the dissemination of a fake Federal Police forensic report shared by far-right Congressman Nikolas Ferreira. Ferreira is a member of Flávio Bolsonaro’s Liberal Party, PL.
But the company now claims that some of this information has been permanently deleted. Faced with this contradiction, Workers Party Congressman Rogério Correia has asked the Regional Electoral Court of Minas Gerais to reject the company’s justification, demand an explanation within 48 hours, and increase the daily fine to $10,000, up to a total cap of $200,000.
Liberal Party Congressman Nikolas Ferreira stands in front of presidential candidate Flavio Bolsonaro and São Paulo state lawmaker Lucas Pavanato during a Bolsonaro rally in São Paulo, Brazil, on October 18, 2026. (Photo by Miguel SCHINCARIOL / AFP via Getty Images)
The request is part of a petition filed on November 14, within the scope of a case investigating allegations of abuse of political power and the misuse of media outlets.
The fraudulent document was shared by the congressman in September in response to a report by Juliana Dal Piva, of ICL Notícias, which revealed conversations and an audio recording between Nikolas and Daniel Vorcaro, the owner of Banco Master.
The alleged report claimed that the Federal Police had conducted an analysis favorable to the congressman regarding the conversations revealed in the report. The Federal Police have denied the authenticity of the document. As ICL Notícias reported on Monday, November 16, the Federal Police has also launched an investigation into the dissemination of this false material.
The new petition primarily questions the sequence of information provided by Meta.
On September 12, one day after the court issued an order to preserve the data, the company stated that it had taken the necessary measures and requested that the order be considered fulfilled.
On November 4, the platform provided technical information on the story posted on Nikolas’s official profile, including the times it was created and deleted. It also requested an additional three business days to complete its review, without mentioning the permanent deletion of any content.
Five days later, on November 9, Meta stated that three of the eight pieces of content covered by the court order had been permanently deleted and that it would be technically impossible to provide some of the requested data.
According to Rogério, the company did not specify when the deletion took place, who carried it out, or what information remains stored.
This distinction is significant because the court had ordered the preservation of these records on September 11. If the data were deleted after this order, the company may have failed to preserve information it was legally required to keep.
If the deletion occurred beforehand, Rogério’s legal team questions why this was not clarified earlier.
Data Could Clarify the Link Between Profiles
The absence of these records also affects a core issue in the investigation: identifying those responsible for the page @nikolasferreirateam, which uses the congressman’s name.
According to the filing, the initial decision by the Regional Electoral Court of Minas Gerais identified this page as the first known instance of the forged document appearing. Records subsequently provided by Meta suggest that another profile, also identified as a source of the material, posted the image only after it had appeared on the first page.
Rogério is requesting that the platform disclose whether the page shares administrators, devices, or other connections with the official account, @nikolasferreiradm.
Nikolas’s defense maintains that the congressman does not know who manages the page bearing his name. For Rogério, the requested data is essential to verify this claim.
Rogério is also seeking information on the reach of the story posted on Nikolas Ferreira’s official profile, including views, shares, and interactions. These records are relevant because the defense has questioned the severity of the post based on the extent of its impact.
Meta reported that the story was published at 1:48 PM on September 3 and taken down at 11:20 AM the following day. According to the petition, a ruling by the Regional Electoral Court of Minas Gerais on October 6 determined that the deletion had been initiated by the account holder.
X Provided Data on a Deleted Post
Another argument presented by Rogério concerns the difference in how the platforms responded to the same court order.
According to the petition, X was able to locate information on a post that the user had already deleted prior to the formal notice. The company provided metrics, timestamps for creation and deletion, access logs, and details regarding the preservation of the files.
Meta, by contrast, stated that it was unable to recover some of the data and submitted technical documents in English, without any translation or detailed explanation.
The filing also cites a decision by the Superior Electoral Court dated November 10, which imposed a fine of $1.3 million on Meta for partial non-compliance with court orders in a separate case.
In the assessment presented by Rogério, this precedent reinforces the need to demand full compliance with the orders. This is all the more important in this case, because the investigation in Minas Gerais still hinges on the data requested.
In addition to increasing the fine, the lawmaker requests that the court order the identification of those responsible for deleting the content, demand information from internet service providers, and consider referring the case to the Regional Electoral Prosecutor’s Office to investigate a potential crime of disobedience.
The petition also requests that this non-compliance be reported to the head of Brazil’s Superior Electoral Court and the Office of the Electoral Inspector General.
The court has yet to review the requests set forth in the filing. Identifying the administrators of the profiles and recovering the records could help clarify the origin and reach of the fabricated report. These are details that are relevant to the adjudication of the electoral case against Nikolas Ferreira.
This article was originally published by ICL Noticias. It was translated by Panamerican Dispatch. You can read the original in Portuguese, here.



