by João Antonio Cunha
Economist and former Finance Minister Luiz Carlos Bresser-Pereira gave a blunt assessment of Brazil’s economic situation in an interview on TV 247 on Thursday. Commenting on the fiscal adjustment proposal the government has presented, he said it pleases neither the financial markets nor the progressive camp and does little more than put off a reckoning with the country’s structural problems.
Luiz Carlos Bresser-Pereira has been an economics professor at Getulio Vargas Foundation since 1959 (photo: ICL)
“This is a proposal that pleases no one, but that’s normal, you just keep kicking the problems down the road,” the former minister said. In Bresser-Pereira’s view, a fair fiscal adjustment would fall on rentiers, who he says carry out a “capture of public assets” through the interest rates charged in Brazil, currently the World’s highest.
He praised the alternative debt restructuring proposal put forward by André Lara Resende, calling it “ingenious.” He added that carrying it out involves political and economic risks, such as a possible run on the dollar. In his assessment, the country’s international reserves of about $380 billion could contain that.
Submission to the “Empire” and the End of the National Bourgeoisie
During the conversation, Bresser-Pereira, who held minster posts in the Jose Sarney and Fernando Henrique Cardoso administrations, said the difficulty of breaking with the neoliberal model comes from the makeup of Brazil’s ruling class. The old national industrial bourgeoisie, represented in the past by figures such as Antônio Ermírio de Moraes and Cláudio Bardella, has disappeared, he said, and a fully financialized elite has taken its place.
“Our elite is a sold out elite, a comprador elite that wants to be protected by the empire and submits to it. It has far more ties to the [American] empire than to the Brazilian people,” he said.
The Macroeconomic Knot: Interest Rates and the Exchange Rate
Bresser-Pereira, who is the founder of the economic theory of New Developmentalism, said Brazil’s real structural obstacle is the distortion of two key macroeconomic prices: the interest rate and the exchange rate. Keeping interest rates high attracts foreign capital and holds the Real artificially strong, hesaid. That destroys the competitiveness of companies that become economically unviable even when they use the best technology available.
The former minister also noted that society as a whole has settled into what he calls “economic populism,” in which an overvalued currency makes immediate consumption easier at the expense of savings and long term investment.
Distinguishing between domestic and foreign debt, Bresser-Pereira criticized the financial market’s alarmism over public accounts. Countries that issue their own currency do not go broke over domestic public debt, he stressed. They go broke when they lack the dollars to meet foreign obligations, a situation that does not currently threaten Brazil.
Criticism of the Central Bank and a Political Assessment
Bresser-Pereira also criticized how the Central Bank, under President Gabriel Galípolo, has handled monetary policy. He said that the slow, timid pace of interest rate cuts is pushing the Brazilian economy into a severe slowdown and close to stagnation. He agreed with the view that using the Selic, Brazil’s benchmark interest rate, to contain cost pressures, such as the ones raised in the debate over ending the 6 day work week, is ineffective. Interest rates act on demand driven inflation, he said, not on inflation driven by supply.
On the political side, Bresser-Pereira said that while President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has a real social commitment, his “narrow, short term Keynesian view” that stimulating consumption alone is enough to sustain development is mistaken.
This article first appeared in Brasil 247, has been translated with express authorization by its editor-in-chief, and can be read in its original Portuguese here.




No doubt.